The Cheapest Used Cars to Insure [Meta-Analysis]

Honest Policy

Honest Policy

There are lots of cars out there. Finding the cheapest used cars to insure can be tricky. After all, there are lots of factors influencing car insurance prices. Elements such as location, age, gender, marital status, education level, mileage, driver riskiness, and credit score are all considered. Another major factor, as might be expected, is the vehicle being insured. Some cars are naturally cheaper to insure than others. When quantifying a vehicle’s risk, insurers tend to look at three primary attributes:

  • The cost to repair or replace the vehicle
  • Safety ratings and cost/frequency of injury claims 
  • Likelihood of theft

cheapest used cars to insure

Consequently, finding a low cost, highly safe vehicle is a good route for the driver who wants to save on their insurance costs (or lessen the blow of getting insurance for their teens).

With that thought in mind, we searched the web for all the studies out there that rank the cheapest used cars to insure. We found six and combined them into the meta-analysis below. 

Once a few car options have been chosen, insurers available in each state can be found here to compare the best policies for them.

 

Understanding Results and How We Calculated Them

To understand the results in the proper context, we first cover some notes and methods about the charts and data gathered.

Viewing the Charts

For viewability, we hid a few columns by default. They are viewable by clicking on the “Columns” button at the top of the chart. Columns not shown: estimated insurance cost, estimated vehicle value, type of vehicle, and source for the data point.

Estimated insurance costs are hidden because each study uses a different driver profile. Consequently, their range of resulting insurance rates cannot be compared apples-to-apples. 

Model Year Considerations

No studies looked at cars from before 2000 so there may be other older options that are cheaper to insure.

Furthermore, the study by Quadrant and Insure.com (as presented on Nerdwallet and TheSimpleDollar) only looked at 2017 vehicles. Similarly, the other Insure.com study only looked at 2006-2008. This naturally skews the results towards those model years—something worth being aware of when reviewing the results.

Combining the Studies

The study conducted by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) did not rank or calculate actual estimated insurance prices for their vehicles. Instead, they opted to organize their list by safety and cost of the vehicle.

To mesh their results with the other studies, we ranked their results first by safety score high-to-low, and then by vehicle price low-to-high.

Cheapest Used Cars to Insure

When it comes to cars, no single company dominates the list. The top ten include both imports like Volvo and domestic producers like Ford (who are also the only two companies to have two cars in the top ten). One of the top picks, Saturn, does not even produce cars anymore. 

Keep in mind that the newer 2017 models on these lists will almost certainly cost more than their older counterparts. They just serve as the best affordable options for drivers looking for newer used cars.

Some particularly affordable highlights here:

  • Kia Spectra, a mechanically reliable budget-friendly option. 
  • Ford Escort, a no-frills but dependable car with decent mileage.
  • Mercury Sable, known for its smooth ride and comfort
  • Saturn SL1, with ratings consistently above 4 stars on cars.com
wdt_ID Year(s) Make Model Tier Est. Insure Price Est. Car Value Classification Source
Year(s) Make Model Tier Est. Insure Price Est. Car Value Classification Source

Cheapest Used SUVs, Minivans, and Trucks to Insure

Topping the list for other vehicles, we find minivans and small SUVs of all flavors. Here, Hondas and Jeeps crop up most in the top 10. As with the cars, the 2017 options that make this list will not likely be as cheap to insure as older models. They are simply the cheapest options from that model year. 

wdt_ID Year(s) Make Model Tier Est. Insure Price Est. Car Value Classification Source
Year(s) Make Model Tier Est. Insure Price Est. Car Value Classification Source

Overall Most Affordable Vehicles to Insure 

Interestingly, there are more SUVs and minivans than cars at the top of the list for the overall cheapest vehicles to insure. But that is misleading since most are from the 2017 studies. It does, however, illustrate how far safety technology has advanced for SUVs in the last ten years (i.e. they roll over a lot less). For more details on insurance losses by make and model, the IIHS has a handy tool that allows readers to compare easily.

Sources of Data

Data was gathered from multiples studies conducted by the organizations listed below:

IN THIS ARTICLE