Honest Policy Logo
Check out all the Carriers on Honesty Policy

Sort By:

21st Century

Claims Rating

76

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

72

SMART SCORE

79

AAA

Claims Rating

88

Industry Rating

90.4

Customer Rating

92

SMART SCORE

90

AIG

Claims Rating

94

Industry Rating

88.9

Customer Rating

80

SMART SCORE

88

Acuity

Claims Rating

96

Industry Rating

93.3

Customer Rating

64

SMART SCORE

84

Alfa

Claims Rating

88

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

80

SMART SCORE

86

Alliance United

Claims Rating

0

Industry Rating

80

Customer Rating

48

SMART SCORE

43

Allied

Claims Rating

80

Industry Rating

96.7

Customer Rating

100

SMART SCORE

92

Allstate

Claims Rating

90

Industry Rating

91.6

Customer Rating

84

SMART SCORE

88

American Family

Claims Rating

96

Industry Rating

89.7

Customer Rating

78

SMART SCORE

88

American National

Claims Rating

92

Industry Rating

89.2

Customer Rating

60

SMART SCORE

80

Ameriprise

Claims Rating

72

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

100

SMART SCORE

87

Amica

Claims Rating

88

Industry Rating

100

Customer Rating

100

SMART SCORE

96

Anchor

Claims Rating

0

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

52

SMART SCORE

47

Arbella

Claims Rating

92

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

72

SMART SCORE

83

Assurance-America

Claims Rating

64

Industry Rating

80

Customer Rating

38

SMART SCORE

61

Austin Mutual

Claims Rating

100

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

84

SMART SCORE

91

Auto-Owners

Claims Rating

96

Industry Rating

100

Customer Rating

82

SMART SCORE

93

Badger Mutual

Claims Rating

100

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

82

SMART SCORE

89

Brethren Mutual

Claims Rating

0

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

50

SMART SCORE

45

Bristol West

Claims Rating

100

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

64

SMART SCORE

85

CSE

Claims Rating

98

Industry Rating

88.3

Customer Rating

66

SMART SCORE

84

Celina

Claims Rating

100

Industry Rating

88.3

Customer Rating

98

SMART SCORE

95

Central Mutual of Ohio

Claims Rating

91

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

88

SMART SCORE

90

Century-National

Claims Rating

0

Industry Rating

80

Customer Rating

50

SMART SCORE

43

Chubb

Claims Rating

100

Industry Rating

95.8

Customer Rating

76

SMART SCORE

91

Cincinnati Insurance

Claims Rating

93

Industry Rating

91.8

Customer Rating

78

SMART SCORE

88

Columbia

Claims Rating

95

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

78

SMART SCORE

86

Commonwealth

Claims Rating

95

Industry Rating

80

Customer Rating

100

SMART SCORE

92

Concord

Claims Rating

98

Industry Rating

86

Customer Rating

44

SMART SCORE

76

Consumers Insurance

Claims Rating

100

Industry Rating

93.3

Customer Rating

75.2

SMART SCORE

89

Cornerstone National

Claims Rating

78

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

90

SMART SCORE

86

Country Financial

Claims Rating

97

Industry Rating

95

Customer Rating

80

SMART SCORE

91

Cumberland

Claims Rating

0

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

64

SMART SCORE

50

Dairyland

Claims Rating

72

Industry Rating

95

Customer Rating

75.6

SMART SCORE

81

Direct Auto

Claims Rating

55

Industry Rating

80

Customer Rating

72.6

SMART SCORE

69

Donegal

Claims Rating

82

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

76.2

SMART SCORE

83

Elephant

Claims Rating

0

Industry Rating

80

Customer Rating

63

SMART SCORE

48

Encompass

Claims Rating

91

Industry Rating

94.1

Customer Rating

66

SMART SCORE

84

Erie

Claims Rating

84

Industry Rating

95

Customer Rating

86.2

SMART SCORE

88

Esurance

Claims Rating

82

Industry Rating

93.3

Customer Rating

80

SMART SCORE

85

Everest National

Claims Rating

0

Industry Rating

93.3

Customer Rating

36

SMART SCORE

43

Farm Bureau Financial Services

Claims Rating

95

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

80

SMART SCORE

88

Farmers

Claims Rating

95

Industry Rating

89.9

Customer Rating

86

SMART SCORE

90

First Chicago

Claims Rating

0

Industry Rating

64

Customer Rating

40

SMART SCORE

35

Foremost Insurance

Claims Rating

93

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

80

SMART SCORE

88

Founders

Claims Rating

0

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

78

SMART SCORE

54

Frankenmuth

Claims Rating

98

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

100

SMART SCORE

96

GAINSCO

Claims Rating

64

Industry Rating

80

Customer Rating

46

SMART SCORE

63

GEICO

Claims Rating

92

Industry Rating

99.6

Customer Rating

80

SMART SCORE

90

Goodville

Claims Rating

88

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

72.8

SMART SCORE

84

Grange

Claims Rating

94

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

80.2

SMART SCORE

88

Grinnell

Claims Rating

94

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

78.6

SMART SCORE

88

Hallmark

Claims Rating

72

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

77

SMART SCORE

78

Hanover

Claims Rating

95

Industry Rating

89.3

Customer Rating

69

SMART SCORE

84

Hastings Mutual

Claims Rating

78

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

68

SMART SCORE

79

Haulers

Claims Rating

82

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

66

SMART SCORE

79

Infinity

Claims Rating

25

Industry Rating

89

Customer Rating

32.4

SMART SCORE

49

Kemper

Claims Rating

0

Industry Rating

84.8

Customer Rating

90

SMART SCORE

58

Liberty Mutual

Claims Rating

98

Industry Rating

87.8

Customer Rating

92

SMART SCORE

93

MAPFRE

Claims Rating

82

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

69.8

SMART SCORE

81

Main Street America

Claims Rating

91

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

62

SMART SCORE

81

Mendota

Claims Rating

40

Industry Rating

80

Customer Rating

58.4

SMART SCORE

59

Mercury

Claims Rating

82

Industry Rating

91

Customer Rating

74

SMART SCORE

82

Metlife

Claims Rating

84

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

80

SMART SCORE

85

Metromile

Claims Rating

0

Industry Rating

80

Customer Rating

83.6

SMART SCORE

55

Nationwide

Claims Rating

93

Industry Rating

94.1

Customer Rating

96

SMART SCORE

94

New Jersey Manufacturers

Claims Rating

99

Industry Rating

93.3

Customer Rating

93

SMART SCORE

95

Occidental

Claims Rating

86

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

35.8

SMART SCORE

69

Oregon Mutual

Claims Rating

96

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

86.2

SMART SCORE

89

PEMCO

Claims Rating

99

Industry Rating

80

Customer Rating

60

SMART SCORE

80

Patriot

Claims Rating

91

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

84.6

SMART SCORE

89

Pekin

Claims Rating

96

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

77.6

SMART SCORE

88

Peninsula

Claims Rating

0

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

80

SMART SCORE

57

Penn National

Claims Rating

93

Industry Rating

83.3

Customer Rating

77.8

SMART SCORE

85

Philadelphia

Claims Rating

67

Industry Rating

96.7

Customer Rating

48.6

SMART SCORE

71

Plymouth Rock

Claims Rating

92

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

79.4

SMART SCORE

85

Progressive

Claims Rating

96

Industry Rating

95.1

Customer Rating

84

SMART SCORE

92

Root

Claims Rating

49

Industry Rating

80

Customer Rating

59.6

SMART SCORE

63

SafeAuto

Claims Rating

49

Industry Rating

80

Customer Rating

50

SMART SCORE

60

Safeco

Claims Rating

86

Industry Rating

87.7

Customer Rating

90

SMART SCORE

88

Safety

Claims Rating

86

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

72.2

SMART SCORE

83

Safeway

Claims Rating

76

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

56

SMART SCORE

74

Secura

Claims Rating

97

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

75.6

SMART SCORE

88

Selective Insurance

Claims Rating

84

Industry Rating

88.6

Customer Rating

66.2

SMART SCORE

79

Shelter Insurance

Claims Rating

92

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

80

SMART SCORE

87

State Auto

Claims Rating

84

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

65.6

SMART SCORE

78

State Farm

Claims Rating

93

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

80

SMART SCORE

88

Stillwater

Claims Rating

92

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

35

SMART SCORE

71

The General

Claims Rating

34

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

90

SMART SCORE

70

The Hartford

Claims Rating

84

Industry Rating

92.3

Customer Rating

82

SMART SCORE

86

Travelers

Claims Rating

98

Industry Rating

96.6

Customer Rating

86

SMART SCORE

93

USAA

Claims Rating

91

Industry Rating

99.5

Customer Rating

96

SMART SCORE

95

Utica

Claims Rating

78

Industry Rating

85

Customer Rating

72.4

SMART SCORE

78

West Bend Mutual

Claims Rating

98

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

85

SMART SCORE

91

Western General

Claims Rating

0

Industry Rating

70

Customer Rating

33

SMART SCORE

34

Westfield

Claims Rating

100

Industry Rating

90

Customer Rating

74.2

SMART SCORE

88

About Honest Policy

What we do instead of simply shopping for the cheapest plicy, we want to help you find the policy that offers the vest value for your situation.

To Accomplish this, Honest Policy offers rates for an unmatched number of insurers, and provide reviews from real customers based on national surveys as well as price comparisons, insurer size and feature information, insurer reliability and purchase options.

Honest Policy also plans to educate user about the insurance industry in order to help them betterunderstand the various terms, coverage options and differences that exist between insurance companies.

What we believe customers should understand their insurance policy and what is covered without hidden surprises. Our goal es to educate consumers and equip them to make informed decisions in order to protect their most valuable assets.

We long for more transparency in the insurance industry. While comparing policies and carrers at Honest Policy, you can be assured all of our data is designed to present an unbiased, fair comparison of your options.